Scarborough Fair Restaurant: Exploring the Pros and Cons

Scarborough fair restaurant


Scarborough Fair Restaurant has garnered attention from both locals and visitors alike, offering an elegant fine dining experience in a beautifully decorated setting. To provide a comprehensive overview, we have analyzed various customer reviews to highlight the pros and cons of dining at this renowned establishment set in a restored farmhouse.

Positive reviews of Scarborough Fair Restaurant

Ambiance and Decor: 

Many reviewers praise the restaurant’s charming and whimsical atmosphere. With beautifully decorated spaces, including a secluded room known as the Octagon and tables along the stairway, Scarborough Fair creates a romantic and cozy ambiance that adds to the overall dining experience.

Attentive Service:

Numerous guests commend the attentive and helpful staff at Scarborough Fair. From knowledgeable servers to polite and professional waitstaff, the restaurant strives to provide excellent customer service, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable dining experience.

Flavorful Cuisine:

Several reviewers express delight in the taste and quality of the food at Scarborough Fair. Dishes are described as flavorful and well-prepared, with standout options such as the seafood medley, rack of lamb chops, and spanakopita appetizer. The menu offers a variety of options to cater to different tastes, including gluten-free selections.

Special Occasion Destination:

Scarborough Fair is often recommended as a go-to restaurant for special occasions. Many customers appreciate the restaurant’s ambiance, making it an ideal choice for celebrating milestones, anniversaries, or romantic evenings. The attention to detail in the decor and service enhances the overall experience.

Negative reviews of Scarborough Fair Restaurant

Inconsistent Food Temperature:

A few guests have mentioned that the food at Scarborough Fair was not served piping hot. While flavors were enjoyable, some dishes arrived warm instead of hot. This inconsistency in food temperature could be a point of improvement for the restaurant.

Price Range:

Scarborough Fair is regarded as a higher-end establishment, which is reflected in its pricing. Some reviewers mention that the restaurant falls in the higher price range, making it more suitable for special occasions or those willing to indulge in a fine dining experience. It may not be an ideal choice for those seeking an everyday dining option.

Occasional Service Lapses:

While the majority of reviewers applaud the attentive service, a few guests have reported instances where they had to wait longer than expected for menus or experienced difficulty in getting the staff’s attention. Though these instances appear to be exceptions, it highlights the importance of consistent service delivery.


Scarborough Fair Restaurant offers a unique and enchanting dining experience with its charming ambiance, attentive service, and flavorful cuisine. It provides an ideal setting for special occasions and memorable evenings. However, occasional inconsistencies in food temperature and higher pricing may be factors to consider. Overall, Scarborough Fair’s strengths outweigh its weaknesses, making it a noteworthy destination for those seeking an exquisite fine dining experience.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this blog post are based on customer reviews and may vary depending on individual experiences. It is always recommended to visit the restaurant and form your own opinion.

Location directions:

 Frequently asked Questions

Q: What is Scarborough Fair Restaurant?

A: Scarborough Fair Restaurant is a dining establishment located in Sea Girt, NJ. It is known for its romantic ambiance and locally sourced ingredients.

Q: What type of cuisine does Scarborough Fair Restaurant offer?

A: Scarborough Fair Restaurant offers New American cuisine.

Q: Where is Scarborough Fair Restaurant located?

A: Scarborough Fair Restaurant is located in Sea Girt, NJ.

Q: Can I make a reservation at Scarborough Fair Restaurant?

A: Yes, you can make a reservation at Scarborough Fair Restaurant. It is recommended to call ahead and reserve a table.

Q: Does Scarborough Fair Restaurant offer takeout options?

A: Yes, Scarborough Fair Restaurant offers takeout. You can place an order by contacting them directly or ordering online.

Q: Is Scarborough Fair Restaurant suitable for special occasions?

A: Yes, Scarborough Fair Restaurant is a popular choice for special occasions such as Valentine’s Day. Its romantic ambiance and delicious food make it a great option for a memorable dining experience.

Q: What are some popular dishes at Scarborough Fair Restaurant?

A: Some popular dishes at Scarborough Fair Restaurant include halibut, scallop, and risotto. These dishes are known for their great taste and use of locally sourced ingredients.

Q: How is the service at Scarborough Fair Restaurant?

A: The service at Scarborough Fair Restaurant is known to be friendly and attentive. The staff is dedicated to providing a pleasant dining experience to all guests.

Q: Can Scarborough Fair Restaurant accommodate private dining events?

A: Yes, Scarborough Fair Restaurant can accommodate private dining events. Whether it is a small gathering or a larger celebration, they have the facilities to cater to your needs.


Written by Explore Opinions is a platform that collects genuine user opinions from sources like Google Maps. We summarize the reviews for you, so you don't have to read them all. Our intuitive categorization and summaries enable visitors get valuable insights about the products, events and places and empower them to make informed decisions.

Mastering Time Management: A Review of the Udemy Free Course

Mastering Time Management: A Review of the Udemy Free Course