Should You Read “Hold On to Your Kids”?

Should You Read "Hold On to Your Kids"?

Parenting is one of the most important yet challenging jobs in the world. With so many external influences like technology and social media, it can be difficult for parents to guide their children’s development and build strong relationships.

The parenting book “Hold On to Your Kids” by Gordon Neufeld and Gabor Maté aims to help parents succeed in this role by emphasizing the importance of parental attachment over peer influence. However, the book has received mixed reviews.

In this blog post, we’ll analyze the key pros and cons reviewers highlighted to help you decide if “Hold On to Your Kids” is worth reading.

The Central Thesis: Why Parental Attachment Matters

Many reviewers agreed that the central thesis of the book around parental attachment is important. The book argues that children are naturally wired to attach to caring adults first as this allows them to develop responsibility, self-esteem and independence with guidance.

However, modern society has shifted focus to peer attachment instead. When children attach to other immature children before caring adults, it can stunt their growth and lead to issues like bullying, violence, promiscuity and more.

The book provides a compelling case for why parents need to prioritize their relationships with children over peer influence from other kids. As one reviewer said, it “gives the reader encouragement to be counter-cultural and foster parental attachment way beyond the time most parents in our culture have relinquished that role to peers.” This core message resonated with many readers.

Practical Advice for Strengthening Parent-Child Bonds

In addition to making a strong case for parental attachment, reviewers also noted the book provides helpful, practical advice. It gives specific strategies and language parents can use to connect with children of different ages, rebuild broken bonds and establish their role as a stable source of warmth, security and guidance.

Several reviewers highlighted this advice as one of the most useful takeaways. With tips parents can directly apply, the book makes the abstract concept of attachment more actionable. This makes it a valuable resource beyond just identifying issues parents may face.

Insights on Modern Parenting Challenges

Many reviewers also appreciated the book for bringing deeper insights to modern parenting challenges like technology and peer culture. It explains how these forces have disrupted traditional community and family bonds. Later chapters give parents strategies to establish boundaries and foster healthy relationships online.

One reviewer called this specific content “the most practical, relevant, true, and hopeful information” they found. For navigating twenty-first century obstacles, readers saw value in the book’s explanatory frameworks.

Critiques of Tone and one-sided Perspectives

However, not all reviews were positive. Some critiqued the book’s judgmental and fear-mongering tone when discussing modern parenting trends or “kids these days.” Several felt it painted peers and children themselves as the source of problems rather than fully acknowledging parental shortcomings.

A number of reviewers also took issue with a lack of objectivity or balanced perspectives. Rather than scientific evidence, it seemed to present the authors’ opinions as facts. This subjective and one-sided nature turned some readers off.

Overly simplistic views of human relationships

Some critiqued the book for presenting an overly simplistic binary view of relationships – that children can only be either fully “parent-oriented” or “peer-oriented” with no middle ground. Reviewers pointed out healthy development involves balance and nuance. It also did not acknowledge that parental influences could become damaging if taken to an extreme.

By not validating the child’s individuality and ignoring abuse dynamics, its advice risked enabling authoritarian parenting styles rather than empowering children.

Difficult writing structure and lack of evidence

Multiple reviewers noted frustrations with the writing structure, finding it repetitive or disorganized. It went over the same points excessively without advancing the narrative. This made it a chore to read rather than engaging.

A number of readers also expressed disappointment that for such a consequential topic, it provided few citations or scientific evidence to back up assertions presented as fact. Reviewers expected a higher standard of academic rigor to substantiate claims.

Not a one-size-fits-all approach

While prioritizing parental bonds is important, some perspectives felt the book failed to acknowledge diversity in family dynamics or children’s personalities. What works well for securely attached kids may not apply universally or address root causes like abuse.

By imposing a parenting style without flexibility, its advice risked doing more harm than good depending on each child’s circumstances. Reviewers advocated for a less rigid, more nuanced approach attentive to individual needs.

Should You Read It?

In summary, “Hold On to Your Kids” makes a compelling case for the significance of parental attachment through practical strategies and insights on modern challenges. However, its one-sided perspectives, repetitive structure and lack of evidence frustrate readers looking for academic thoroughness on such a consequential topic.

While the core message resonates, some critiques its potentially harmful application without balance or Tailoring to each family’s dynamics.

For parents wanting to strengthen bonds but open to flexible styles, the advice could prove useful. But those seeking a well-rounded, evidence-based parenting resource may find it lacking nuance and objectivity. Readers should approach it critically rather than treating recommendations as universal truths.

Overall, the book provokes important discussions but may require supplemental viewing points for a holistic understanding of children’s needs. If read selectively with an open mind, elements could still aid contemplation on building healthy relationships.

Buy the book on Amazon through our affiliate link:

Note: We will earn small commission if you buy through this link (at no extra cost to you).


Written by Explore Opinions is a platform that collects genuine user opinions from sources like Google Maps. We summarize the reviews for you, so you don't have to read them all. Our intuitive categorization and summaries enable visitors get valuable insights about the products, events and places and empower them to make informed decisions.

carote cookware set

CAROTE Nonstick Pots and Pans Set Review: Pros and Cons

google ads masterclass

Google Ads Masterclass Udemy Course – Reviews Summary